A Quebec insurance referral serviceClient areaFREN
Quick quoteQuote

Auto insurance claims in Quebec: impact on your payments and insurability

How many auto claims are too many? Find out what impact they have on your premium, your insurability and how long it takes for them to disappear.

Auto insurance claims in Quebec: impact on your payments and insurability

Introduction

In Quebec, every car insurance claim can affect your payments and even your ability to insure yourself in the long term. Many drivers ask themselves: how many claims are too many? Can you become uninsurable? How long does it take for a claim to be deleted from the file?

In this article, we explain how claims affect your premiums, what can make a driver uninsurable and after how long a claim disappears from your history.

1. How claims affect your car insurance payments

Every claim you make to your insurer can increase your premium. But the impact depends on a number of factors:

a) Type of claim

Some claims have a greater impact on your premium than others:

  • At-fault claims: If you are found to be at fault in an accident, your premium is likely to increase considerably.
  • Not-at-fault claims: An accident for which you are not responsible can also affect your premium, but to a much lesser extent.
  • Claims for theft, vandalism or glass breakage: These can increase your premium if they are repeated.
  • Claims for small amounts: Insurers sometimes consider that an insured who often claims for small amounts is more at risk.

b) Number of claims

Insurers assess risk according to the number of claims over a given period. A single faulty claim can be enough to increase your premium by 10 to 50%, depending on the severity of the accident and your track record.

Here's an idea of the impact based on the number of faulty claims:

Number of faulty claims Impact on premium
1 claim in 5 years 10% to 50% increase
2 claims in 3 years Significant increase (50 to 100%), some insurers may refuse to insure you
3 claims in 3 years You could be turned down by several traditional insurers and have to turn to a specialized insurer.

Note: These figures are estimates and may vary depending on the insurer and the insured's specific conditions.

2. Can you become uninsurable after too many claims?

Yes, an insured who makes too many claims in a short space of time may be deemed "too risky" by insurers and have his or her policy cancelled. In this case, it becomes difficult (and costly) to find a new policy.

Here's what can make you uninsurable:

  • Too many faulty claims in a short space of time (e.g. 3 in 3 years).
  • Several successive small claims (glass breakage, theft, vandalism).
  • A record of problem driving in addition to claims (accidents, major tickets, license suspension).

If you are turned down by several insurers, you may be forced to take out high-risk insurance, which is much more expensive.

Would you like to compare different insurers?

Use our free quote tool to quickly obtain several quotes tailored to your profile and needs.

3. After how many years is a claim deleted from the file?

In Quebec, claims generally remain in your insurance file for six years, but their impact diminishes over time.

  • 1 to 3 years after the claim: Your premium is still affected.
  • 4 to 6 years after the claim: Its impact gradually diminishes.
  • After 6 years: The claim generally disappears from your insurance file and should no longer affect your payments.

Insurers rely on data from the Fichier central des sinistres automobiles (FCSA), a register that records the history of claims. After six years, a claim no longer appears in this file.

4. How can I avoid a premium increase after a claim?

If you have to make a claim, here are some strategies to minimize the impact on your auto insurance payments:

  • Opt for a higher deductible: A higher deductible (e.g. $1,000 instead of $500) can discourage minor claims and reduce your premium.
  • Don't claim for minor damage: If the cost of repairs is close to your deductible, it's better to pay out of pocket.
  • Take advantage of an accident waiver: Some insurers offer a waiver for the first claim at fault, preventing a premium increase.
  • Shopping around for insurance: After an increase, compare offers from other insurers to find a better premium.

Conclusion

Car insurance claims in Quebec have a direct impact on your payments, and can even make insurance more difficult to obtain after several claims. In general, a faulty claim increases the premium for several years, but disappears after six years of FCSA.

To avoid becoming uninsurable or paying too much, it's important to manage your claims and adopt good insurance practices. Need to compare the best premiums after a claim? Use our free quote tool to find the best insurance for your situation!

This guide gives general information. To know what suits your situation, talk to a certified representative.

From reading to a quote.

One request, several offers from certified firms in Quebec. Free, no commitment.